Somewhere in Alabama right now, one woman is holding the whole holiday together. She has the cornbread dressing timeline memorized, every cousin’s gift wrapped and hidden, and a running list of who’s bringing the Lane cake this year. From the first evening stroll through the lights at Bellingrath Gardens to the last plate cleared on Christmas night, she runs the show. This year, she gets a bottle that matches her energy, and When She Was King makes two of them. Smoke and Mask are bold red blends from Paso Robles, California, made for women who take the crown instead of waiting for it. Pour one for her, wrap one for her, or better yet, do both.
When She Was King
When She Was King is a boutique Paso Robles label from founders John and Stacy Reinert, built on one simple belief: strength and elegance belong in the same glass. The labels honor women who stood up and stood out, and the wines carry that same confidence from the first pour.
The grapes grow on the west side of Paso Robles in the Templeton Gap, where cool Pacific winds sweep through the hills and make the vines dig deep to survive. That struggle shows up in the glass as concentration and character. Both wines are GSM blends, the classic Rhône-style trio of Grenache, Syrah, and Mourvèdre. Grenache brings lively red fruit, Syrah adds weight and dark spice, and Mourvèdre lays down an earthy, steady backbone. What separates Smoke from Mask is simply which grape gets to lead.
The project came to life with guidance from two of Paso’s most respected winemakers, Stephan Asseo of L'Aventure and Conor McMahon of Full Draw Vineyards. The wines are released by allocation, so when a bottle lands on an Alabama shelf, it's worth grabbing.
When She Was King 2024 Mask

Mask is the quiet one at the party who turns out to be the most interesting person in the room. Mourvèdre leads this blend (60% Mourvèdre, 20% Grenache, 20% Syrah), giving it an earthy, soulful depth, while Grenache and Syrah lift the fruit and bring a little warmth. Mourvèdre rarely gets top billing in California, which makes Mask a fun discovery for the wine lover who thinks she's tried it all. It keeps shifting in the glass, so the longer she lingers over it, the more it has to say.
Nose: Black cherry and dried lavender with a soft hint of cedar.
Palate: Ripe fig and dark cherry layered with leather and a savory edge, balanced and polished.
Finish: Long, earthy, and elegant, with a gentle trail of spice.
Best enjoyed: After the kids are finally in bed and the wrapping paper is cleared, by candlelight, with a slow-cooked supper. Give it about 30 minutes in a decanter and serve just below room temperature.
When She Was King 2024 Smoke

If Mask is the mystery, Smoke is the grand entrance. Syrah takes charge here (80% Syrah, 10% Grenache, 10% Mourvèdre), bringing dark fruit, cracked pepper, and a touch of wilderness. Grenache adds a bright pop of red plum, and Mourvèdre rounds it out with savory spice and structure. It's plush, layered, and bold, the bottle you open when the house is full, the fire is going, and somebody just put the good record on.
Nose: Violet and blackberry with a crack of black pepper.
Palate: Blackberry compote, charred herbs, and dusty cocoa over a texture that's plush but firm.
Finish: Slow and smoldering, hanging around well after the last sip.
Best enjoyed: Opened about an hour before the Christmas Eve feast and poured by the fireplace. This one rewards a little patience, so let it breathe in a decanter.
Alabama Holiday Pairings and a Smoke Sour
Mask pairings: Mask loves anything rich and slow-cooked. Try it with braised short ribs on Christmas Eve, or with a roasted duck from a hunter's haul in the Mobile-Tensaw Delta. Its earthy, savory side also plays beautifully with sage-heavy cornbread dressing and a pan of roasted sweet potatoes and root vegetables.
Smoke pairings: Smoke wants something with a little char. Set it next to a smoked pork shoulder, a peppery beef tenderloin, or a skillet of Conecuh sausage from Evergreen sizzling for the Christmas morning crowd. Wild mushroom dishes and anything dusted with smoked paprika are fair game, too.
Try it as a Smoke Sour. This riff on the classic New York Sour floats a splash of Smoke over a bourbon sour, so it looks as good on the holiday table as it tastes.
- 60 ml bourbon
- 22 ml fresh lemon juice
- 22 ml simple syrup
- 1 egg white (optional, for a silky foam)
- 30 ml When She Was King Smoke
Shake the bourbon, lemon juice, simple syrup, and egg white hard without ice, then shake again with ice. Strain into a rocks glass over a large cube. Slowly pour the Smoke over the back of a bar spoon so it floats in a deep red layer on top.
Mask, on the other hand, is best poured on its own. A wine called Mask has nothing to hide behind.
Smoke or Mask? Pick her bottle.
The woman who runs Christmas already knows what she likes. If she’s the calm, steady force who keeps everyone fed and happy, she’s a Mask. If she walks into the room and the party starts, she’s a Smoke. Either way, she earned the crown long before the tree went up. Look for When She Was King at your favorite Alabama wine shop or restaurant this season, and ask early, because allocated wines like these don’t wait around.